Words Like Snow and Steel: A Winterglass Review

Hello, traveler!

Let’s take a peek at Winterglass, a novella written by Benjanun Sriduangkaew. It’s the first installment of the Her Pitiless Command series, an epic fantasy lesbian retelling of Hans Christian Andersenโ€™s The Snow Queen, which takes place in a world based on Southeast and South Asian cultures where the primary form of magic-technology is powered by the dead.

Synopsis:

The city-state Sirapirat once knew only warmth and monsoon. When the Winter Queen conquered it, she remade the land in her image, turning Sirapirat into a country of snow and unending frost. But an empire is not her only goal. In secret, she seeks the fragments of a mirror whose power will grant her deepest desire.

At her right hand is General Lussadh, who bears a mirror shard in her heart, as loyal to winter as she is plagued by her past as a traitor to her country. Tasked with locating other glass-bearers, she finds one in Nuawa, an insurgent whoโ€™s forged herself into a weapon that will strike down the queen.

To earn her place in the queenโ€™s army, Nuawa must enter a deadly tournament where the losersโ€™ souls are given in service to winter. To free Sirapirat, she is prepared to make sacrifices: those she loves, herself, and the complicated bond slowly forming between her and Lussadh.

If the splinter of glass in Nuawa’s heart doesn’t destroy her first.


My Rating: โ˜…โ˜…โ˜…

(A rather unrelated note: have you ever seen a more beautiful cover, dear traveler? Its artist, Anna Dittman, is an absolute legend!)

Maybe I just donโ€™t have enough brain cells to understand this book properly (there are no wrinkles up in my cranium, yo. Up there, itโ€™s as smooth as the rolling sea), but I must say: Winterglass was rather difficult to dig through!

 

First, the positive: 

I loved Winterglassโ€™s poetry. That’s the best way to describe this book โ€” itโ€™s poetry through and through. Sriduangkaewโ€™s style was evocative, and left me staring at its pages in dazed, yearning contemplation. 

In lucky moments, I could feel the chill of the Winter Queen, gazing at me with her dark, glacial eyes. Faintly, I could hear the chanting of the spectators as Nuawa, the Lightning, grappled with opponents in the arena. If I squinted, I could see the crystalline colors of the bustling world of Sirapirat in all its glory. 

Here are some of my favorite lines, out-of-context:

โœง โ€œShe imagined then that the queen was iron and rime underneath too, dense strong bones inside the annihilating white of her skin.โ€ 

โœง โ€œThere was a time, young and full of ideal, when those words would have stung her tongue and stoppered her throat. No longer; now they are rote. Existence is a performance.โ€ 

โœง โ€œUnwise to say, she realizes as she speaks, but her reason is lagging far behind her mouth.โ€

โœง โ€œTime dilates.โ€

โœง โ€œIf she must kill them all over again, she will. It will be menial, but it is a language in which her fluency is total.โ€ 

โœง โ€œThe gun is firm in her grip, the metal of it the same as it has always been, agnostic to circumstances and indifferent to emotion.โ€

And the best line, in my eyes:

โœง โ€œ…the wet slap of viscera meeting glass…โ€

Let me tell you, traveler: Iโ€™m a sucker for a wet slap!

I shiver at the thought of these phrases and sentences. They’re so vivid โ€” so wild โ€” so sexy. As my fellow Generation Z-folk say, we love to see it

Tangentially, I learned so many new words through Winterglass. I deeply stan a novel with a lexicon. (Pleat and wrinkle my brain, amen and please!)

Here are a few terms I picked up, along with their definitions as provided by Google and Wikipediaโ€™s dictionaries:

AbattoirA slaughterhouse.
Apocryphal Of doubtful authenticity, although widely circulated as being true.
KatabasisA descent of some type, such as moving downhill, the sinking of the winds or sun, a military retreat, a trip to the underworld, or a trip from the interior of a country down to the coast.
OneirologyThe scientific study of dreams.
OpprobriousExpressing scorn or criticism.
PhantasmagoriaA sequence of real or imaginary images like those seen in a dream.
RictusA fixed grimace or grin.

(Watch me weave these into my works-in-progress and English essays somehow, wink wink wink!)

I have sung my praises. And now, to climb โ€”

The book had its shortcomings: 

Truly, Winterglass was poetry. But poetry alone cannot shape a story. 

For all the novel’s beautiful writing, none of this prose gave me a good sense of place or character (despite its many breathtaking environmental descriptions).

As a result, I was unable to engross myself into the novel and ground myself in the chaos of the narrative.

Was there even a narrative at all, I wonder? Winterglass was a string of pearls I did not know how to link.

The elevated vocabulary, as fantastic as it was, contributed to my confusion. (Itโ€™s because I am, at times, a fool. This I can confirm. Still โ€”) Why use this complicated, little-known word here? I inquired, in different contexts while reading. Why not use something simpler, which may convey meaning more effectively? Sometimes, Winterglassโ€™s archaic โ€” though gorgeous โ€” terminology distracted from the course of a scene.

I struggle to concretely recall the winding plot, or how Nuawa changed throughout that plot. The relationships didnโ€™t feel properly conveyed โ€” perhaps this was on account of the distance I felt towards Nuawa, Lussadh, and the people they encountered. Winterglass‘s intricate composition detached me from the intentions and thoughts of the protagonists.

With Winterglass, I had high expectations. Its preview-prologue and synopsis, both of which I perused on Goodreads, intrigued me. I was excited to read an Asian-inspired fantasy (based on the story of the Snow Queen, no less!), and overjoyed when I heard that the novel featured sapphic protagonists and genderqueer representation.

But I didnโ€™t love its story as much as I wanted to. I hoped to receive a diamond, but was instead disappointed by scattered, blunted shards. 

Spectacular language buried, rather than bolstered, Winterglassโ€™s coherency. 

Itโ€™s worth the read nonetheless. A gem is a gem, no matter how scratched. Iโ€™m definitely reading the sequel โ€” and Iโ€™ll let you know when I do.

Thank you for reading my first book review on this blog! Stay hydrated, and take care of yourself!


Up next on this blog: a review of the film Parasite (2020)! Don’t miss it!

Leave a comment